Can I Claim Disability Insurance Premiums on My Taxes?

Disability insurance is a financial lifeline for Canadians facing health challenges that prevent them from working. As an aging population increases the demand for long-term care, a recent CBC article highlights the question how disability insurance benefits fit into retirement and tax planning. While many focus on the income support these benefits provide, fewer consider the tax implications of disability insurance premiums—and how missteps could impact their financial stability.

At Whitten & Lublin, we understand that these financial decisions often intersect with complex employment law issues Many Ontarians are now asking: Can I claim disability insurance premiums on my taxes? The answer depends on your specific situation, including whether you’re self-employed, part of a group insurance plan, or managing employer-paid premiums.

In this guide, we’ll explain when disability insurance premiums are tax-deductible, when they aren’t, and how to make informed decisions that protect your financial security. And if you’re facing challenges with your disability insurance claim or need support with workplace disputes, our team of experienced Toronto employment lawyers is here to help.

Disability Insurance Premiums & Taxation

The tax treatment of both the premiums you pay and the benefits you receive depends who pays the premiums and the nature of your employment.

When considering whether you can deduct disability insurance premiums on your taxes, we have to differentiate between group disability insurance plans, personal disability policies, and wage loss replacement plans.

When Are Disability Insurance Premiums Tax-Deductible?

For most Ontarians, disability coverage is not tax-deductible, but there are exceptions.

1. Employer-Paid Premiums:

If your employer pays the group disability insurance premiums for a plan, these premiums are generally tax-deductible for the employer as a business expense. However, this benefit has a flip side:

Taxable Benefit to Employees: The premiums paid on your behalf are considered a taxable benefit, meaning they will be included in your employee’s income for tax purposes.
Tax Treatment of Benefits: If you need to claim long-term disability benefits under this plan, the benefits will typically be considered taxable income, which could impact your tax return significantly.

2. Self-Employed Individuals:

For self-employed workers, the rules differ:

Non-Deductible Premiums: Premiums paid for personal disability policies are considered a personal expense and are not tax-deductible.
Tax-Free Benefits: The upside is that the disability benefits received from such policies are usually tax-free, as the premiums were paid with after-tax dollars.
Potential Deduction for Business Expenses: If the disability insurance is part of a wage loss replacement plan specifically designed to cover business income, you may be able to deduct premiums as a business expense. However, this is rare and should be discussed with a tax professional.

3. Private Health Services Plans (PHSPs):

In limited circumstances, if your disability insurance is part of a broader PHSP, you might qualify for a partial tax deduction. These plans often combine disability insurance coverage with other health insurance plan premiums, such as dental insurance premiums, potentially offering additional tax credits.

When Are Disability Insurance Premiums Not Deductible?

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) maintains strict rules on tax deductions for insurance premiums:

Personal Policies: Premiums paid for personal disability policies are generally not tax-deductible, as these are considered personal expenses under the Income Tax Act.
Group Plans Paid with After-Tax Dollars: If you contribute to a group insurance plan with after-tax dollars, these premiums are also not deductible. However, the disability benefits received under this arrangement are usually tax-free.

The rationale is to prevent artificial tax benefits—allowing a deduction for premiums while also receiving tax-free benefits would create an unfair advantage.

The Taxability of Benefits

Understanding how your disability insurance benefits will be taxed is just as important as knowing whether your premiums are deductible:

Tax-Free Benefits: When premiums are paid with after-tax dollars, the benefits you receive are typically tax-free, providing clear financial security during periods of illness or disability.
Taxable Benefits: If your employer pays the premiums, any long-term disability insurance benefits received are generally taxable, impacting your personal income and possibly pushing you into a higher tax bracket.

How Whitten & Lublin Can Help You Take Control

At Whitten & Lublin, we empower Ontarians to understand their employment rights and navigate their options with confidence.

When it comes to disability insurance claims, workplace disputes, or any other employment law issues, our team is in your corner to help you take control of your outcome. We can:

Provide Legal Guidance: Whether you’re disputing a disability insurance claim or negotiating with an insurance company, we offer strategic support.
Assist with Employment Disputes: If your employer’s group disability insurance plan involves unfair labour practices or human rights violations, we’ll help you protect your rights.
Clarify Your Rights: From layoffs and temporary disability to issues surrounding workplace accommodations, our Toronto employment lawyers are ready to stand in your corner.

For more information on how we can assist with disability insurance claims, visit our Disability Insurance Claims page. Call 416 640 2667 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.

Request a Consultation