Where to Claim Disability from Insurance Company on Income Tax What Ontario Employees Need to Know

Where to Claim Disability from Insurance Company on Income Tax: What Ontario Employees Need to Know

When you’re dealing with a serious illness or injury, the last thing you want to worry about is how your disability benefits will affect your taxes. Yet, every year, many Canadians find themselves asking: Where do I claim disability from my insurance company on my income tax?

The Income Tax Act lays out the rules on taxable income, including disability insurance benefits, but those rules aren’t always clear. If your employer paid the insurance premiums, your benefits may be taxable, but if you paid them yourself, they may be tax-free. It sounds simple—but when you’re navigating paperwork from your insurance company, trying to understand group disability insurance premiums, and figuring out what to put on your tax return, it can quickly become overwhelming.

And that’s just the tax side of things. What if your claim gets denied? What if your employer pressures you to return to work before you’re ready? What if you’re let go while on long-term disability leave?

At Whitten & Lublin, we help employees protect their disability benefits and fight back against unfair denials or employer interference. If you’re worried about how your disability coverage impacts your job and your future, here’s what you need to know.

Are Your Disability Benefits Taxable? It All Comes Down to Who Pays the Premiums

When it comes to disability insurance benefits, the tax implications boil down to a simple rule: who pays the premiums determines whether the benefits are taxable.

  • If your employer pays the premiums: Your disability benefits are considered taxable income, and you’ll need to report them on your tax return.
  • If you pay the premiums yourself (with after-tax dollars): Your benefits are tax-free, meaning you don’t need to report them as income.

This applies to both short-term disability (STD) benefits and long-term disability (LTD) benefits. The same tax treatment applies whether you’re covered through a wage loss replacement plan or a private insurance policy.

Where to Claim Disability from Insurance Company on Income Tax

If your disability insurance benefits are considered taxable income, here’s where to report it to the Canada Revenue Agency:

  • Employer-Provided Disability Benefits: Enter the amount from your T4A on Line 10400 (“Other employment income”) of your tax return.
  • Canada Pension Plan (CPP) Disability Benefits: If you receive CPP disability benefits, report them on Line 11400 (“CPP disability benefits”).
  • Lump-Sum Payments: If your insurer issues a lump sum for past lost earnings, it’s typically taxable income and must be reported accordingly.

How Disability Insurance Affects Your Pay and Job Security

Are Employers Allowed to Deduct Disability Premiums from My Pay?

Yes. Many employers deduct STD and LTD insurance premiums directly from employee paychecks through payroll deductions. If your employer pays the entire premium, the benefits received will be taxable income.

Can My Employer Fire Me While I’m on Long-Term Disability?

This is one of the most stressful questions employees face. The short answer? Yes—but only under specific circumstances.

Your employer cannot fire you just because you’re on disability leave. That would be a human rights violation. However, an employer can terminate an employee if they can prove the termination was due to legitimate business reasons and not because of the disability.

If your employer lets you go while you’re on long-term disability leave, you may be entitled to:

  • A wrongful dismissal claim
  • A human rights complaint for discrimination
  • A larger severance package

If you suspect your employer is pushing you out while you’re on disability, speak to an employment lawyer as soon as possible.

What If My Disability Claim Is Denied?

Many employees find out the hard way that insurance companies look for reasons to deny claims. Common reasons include:

  • “Insufficient medical evidence”
  • Disagreements over whether you can work
  • Missed paperwork or deadlines

If your disability insurance claim is denied, don’t give up. You have options:

  • Appeal through the insurance company (but keep in mind that insurers tend to favour themselves)
  • Sue the insurance company to enforce your benefits
  • Hold your employer accountable if they interfered with your benefits or pressured you to return too soon

At Whitten & Lublin, we have helped countless employees fight back Do I Have to Return to Work If My Insurer Says I Can?

Many employees feel trapped when their insurance company decides they are “fit to return to work,” even when their doctor disagrees. Your insurance company’s opinion is not the final word.

Here’s what you need to know:

  • If your doctor says you’re not ready to return, you do not have to go back.
  • Your employer must accommodate your condition if you return with medical restrictions.
  • If your employer refuses, this may be a human rights violation.

If you feel pressured to return before you’re ready, an employment lawyer can help protect your rights.

When to Call an Employment Lawyer

Understanding where to claim disability from insurance on income tax is important, but the bigger issue for many employees is whether they are getting the benefits they deserve and whether their employer is treating them fairly.

You should speak to an employment lawyer if:

  • Your disability insurance claim was denied, and you don’t know what to do next.
  • Your employer is pressuring you to return before you are medically ready.
  • You were terminated while on long-term disability leave.

Beyond the tax implications, the real issue is whether you’re receiving the benefits you’re entitled to—and whether your employer is treating you fairly.

If you’re struggling with a denied claim, employer pressure, or workplace retaliation, our team of Toronto employment lawyers is in your corner. Call 416 640 2667 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.

Related Posts